Attached Garages and Your Indoor Air Quality
Attached Garages and Indoor Air Quality
Canadians can spend an average of 90 per cent of their time indoors. Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) and others have published material on how to provide good indoor air quality (IAQ). This About Your House discusses the risks of attached garages and how to keep car-based pollutants out of your house.
Attached garages are convenient, and are a common part of suburban houses. The attachment could be to the side of the house, with a room over top of the garage, or even as a part of what traditionally is the basement (see figures 1, 2 and 3).
Figure 1 — Garage attached at the side of the house
Figure 2 — Room over top of the garage
Figure 3 — Garage as part of the basement
Automobiles give off pollution. Starting a car in a garage, even with the garage door wide open, can result in a higher concentration of combustion pollutants (for example, carbon monoxide) in the garage and house.
Driving a car into the garage and closing the door results in emissions of various chemicals over the next several hours as the engine and its fluids cool down. The pollutants in the garage air can be drawn into the house over time.
This is not just a theoretical problem. In a survey done by Health Canada in more than 100 houses in Windsor, Ontario, the results were very clear.
Houses with attached garages had measurable concentrations of benzene (a gasoline-related pollutant) in their indoor air. Houses with no garages or detached garages had little or no benzene. This is true of a host of other airborne chemicals. The study revealed that pollutants in attached garages can find their way into the house.
There are also secondary sources of pollutants in garages, apart from car-based emissions. There are many gas-powered appliances, such as lawn mowers, chain saws and edging tools whose emission systems are not as good as those found in cars. Chemicals such as pesticides and herbicides are also sources of pollutants.
One disconcerting fact is that garage-to-house air movement is not obvious or straightforward. In the 1990s, when the first inexpensive carbon monoxide (CO) sensors became commercially available, many started going off without an evident source of carbon monoxide. Responders such as utilities and fire departments often wrote off the incidents as false alarms, prompted by over-sensitive CO detectors. However, research in Minnesota showed that the time delay of CO entry to the house from the garage could be a factor. When a cold car engine starts up in the garage, even with the main garage door open, it can generate up to several hundred parts per million of carbon monoxide gas in the garage. Once the car has left and the garage door is closed, the garage may still hold a relatively high CO concentration for hours. Air leaking from the garage to the house can cause the CO level in the house to start climbing. After several hours, the house CO level is high enough to set off the CO alarm, but by then the garage is low in CO and is not recognized as a source.
How Garage Air Gets Into Your House
It can be difficult to understand how and why garage air moves into the house. After all, there is at least one layer of drywall between the house and the garage, and a significant amount of insulation. The door from the attached garage to the house typically has weather-stripping and a spring to hold the door closed. So how does air enter?
Air can move through small cracks in the walls between the house and the garage, around the weather-stripping of the garage to house door and through the ceiling of the garage to any room that may be located above. There are many tiny holes and cracks that permit this air movement to take place and they exist in all houses. However, it takes a sophisticated test with specialized tools, such as a blower door and leakage detection equipment, to find the leaks.
Field tests by CMHC have discovered that the walls (and perhaps ceilings) between garages and the house can be as air leaky as the rest of the house. Some houses get most of their “fresh air” through the garage. One or two of those tested had so little leakage that there was no measurable air movement through the walls between house and garage. However, most garages have some air leaks, roughly in proportion to the size of the exterior wall.
But air movement into a house requires both a hole and a pressure difference. Does a pressure difference exist? Yes. CMHC measured the pressure difference across the house-garage wall and the house pressures are often lower than garage pressures, especially in winter. This is quite common in colder weather. Having exhaust fans or vented heating appliances also creates lower pressures inside the house, and garage air is drawn in through the leaks.
Preventing Garage-to-House Transfer in New Houses
The best way to prevent garage air entry into the house is to make sure that there are no leaks between the garage and the house. In new construction, this should be easy. The builder should make the interface walls and ceilings as airtight as possible. This is more readily done if the builder knows that reducing pollution transfer from the garage is a priority.
The builder should:
- Ensure the airtightness of the garage ceiling and walls that are next to the house, before the insulation is installed and before installing drywall on the garage side.
- Check all wall-to-wall junctions or wall-to-floor junctions and seal them. If the top of the basement wall is exposed in the garage, that header space can be notoriously leaky.
- Diligently seal all penetrations from the house to the garage (wiring, central vacuum exhaust and so on).
- Keep mechanical systems (furnaces, water heaters and so on) out of the garage. While most Canadian builders would not consider putting mechanical systems in the garage, it is common practice in parts of the U.S. The few Canadian houses that CMHC has tested (in B.C.) with heating systems located in the garage showed high levels of garage pollutants in house air.
Preventing Garage-to-House Pollution Transfer in Existing Houses
It is much harder to prevent air movement from a garage to a house in an existing house. In an older house, leaks can be difficult to locate and seal, but the effort may still prove worthwhile. Make sure the weatherstripping around the door to the garage is continuous and in good shape. If the garage has no drywall on the wall between the garage and the house, sealing air leaks may be simple, as holes and cracks through the wall can be more easily accessed and sealed. Spray foam insulation can be used to seal and insulate the wall between the house and garage but this is not typically a job for a do-it-yourselfer. Afterwards, drywall can be installed, taped and sealed to further reduce air leakage and improve fire safety. If there is drywall on the outside wall and it is simply screwed on the wall and is unfinished, removing the drywall gives access to the interior space that can be sealed, filled with spray foam insulation and then covered with tape and sealed drywall. A similar approach can be taken to seal the ceiling space between the garage and any rooms above. This can help keep the floors warmer as well as reduce energy costs.
Another approach involves installing an exhaust fan such as a good quality, properly sized, bathroom fan or a more commercial unit in the garage to vent garage air outside. By operating the fan, the garage becomes depressurized relative to the house thereby preventing air movement from the garage to the house, even if leaks exist.. This will not impact to any great extent on house heating costs but there will be an electrical cost to run a fan.
A properly sized and installed garage exhaust fan may lower the garage pressure enough for airflow through the holes to go from the house to the garage, rather than the garage to the house. Check the pressure difference by opening the door to the house just a crack and feeling for air movement from the house to the garage. A smouldering string can also be used to detect air movement. If air is moving into the garage, the fan is causing the pressure to act in the right direction. This will help ensure that garage pollutants do not enter house air.
To avoid high electrical costs, choose an exhaust fan with low energy consumption. To further reduce fan usage, have the fan activated for a period (for example, one hour) after the garage door is used.
Continuous use of the exhaust fan is recommended if:
- There are a lot of noxious chemicals in the garage. Better yet, consider sending them to a hazardous waste disposal site.
- The garage is used to store or maintain older vehicles with higher emissions.
- There is a lot of coming to and going from the garage through the main garage door.
What to do
All buyers of new houses should confirm that their builder is aware of this issue and takes measures to do a good job of sealing air leakage paths. It is the only easy time to seal the air leakage points. An effective air sealing approach is far better than installing an exhaust fan after the fact.
Owners of existing houses have harder choices. If there is evident and annoying transfer of odours and drafts from the garage to the rooms next to the garage, the leaks should be located and sealed. If that task is too onerous or expensive, the garage exhaust fan solution could be considered.
Finally, if the attached garage is not used for vehicles (as is often the case) and there are no other major chemical sources stored in the garage such as gasoline, solvent, cleaners, etc., garage-to-house air movement should not be a significant problem even if it does occur.